"We
are generally the better persuaded by the reasons we discover ourselves than by
those given to us by others." - Blaise Pascal
Many
teams and businesses today are attracted to the romantic notion of being a "big
happy family." The difficulty with this is that somebody gets stuck being the
parent. And it’s the parent who often finds themselves trying to keep everyone
happy.
The
Perils of Paternalism
The
paternalistic view of leadership is one in which the leader plays the role of a
benevolent ruler who makes all important decisions, controls all important
information, does all the important thinking, and basically directs all the
important activities of the organization as he (or she) sees fit. Workers are
there to do the work as directed and to seek information or solutions to
problems from the leader.
According
to research by Jim Laub, Ed.D., most organizations operate with a paternalistic
view of leadership and that, more than
any other reason, hinders them from becoming truly collaborative and effective.
This kind of benevolent rule has the effect of producing a child-like response
in employees who readily accept that their leaders know more, are wiser, and
should be followed. This abdication of their own responsibility to lead has
far-reaching effects. When employees are encouraged to take on the role of
children, the result is a transactional form of leadership that operates more
on compliance rather than true individual motivation.
Making
the Switch
A
healthy organization is one in which people talk and act as partners for the
good of each person and the organization as a whole. When people at all levels
trust and respect one another and encourage active participation and
leadership, the organization as a whole prospers.
Are
you tired of feeling like a counselor, mediating disputes about workplace music
volume and who took Nicole’s lunch?
Leaders who take on the role of parent may find themselves feeling
frustrated, and asking questions like, "Why does it seem like people need
constant guidance in playing well with others?" and "Why won’t they take any
responsibility?"
Learn
to step out of the role of benevolent parent, download our free e-Book: Leading
Your Team: Making the Switch from Frustrated Parent to Collaborative Community
Builder.